Fans Or Dehumidifiers For Basements: Which Is Best?

Charlie D Paige profile pic

Do you have a basement that has too much moisture in it? If so, you might be looking for the best way to remove it. For example, you may have a bathroom in your basement that simply does not get rid of moisture appropriately.

If you want to make your basement or comfortable, you might be thinking about getting a dehumidifier or a fan. Of course, one option is not universally better than the other, but it is important to think about your individual situation so you can decide which of these is best for your needs.

Therefore, it’s time to look at the benefits and drawbacks of each choice so you can figure out which one is right for you. What do you need to know?

Quick Hits: The Big Differences Between a Fan and a Dehumidifier

First, it’s important to keep a few major differences in mind when comparing a fan versus a dehumidifier. A fan is designed to circulate air throughout your basement. This can be great for making sure your room is well-ventilated. You can make sure there is a constant supply of fresh air so the air does not feel stale. Fans are far less complicated than dehumidifiers. They are incredibly easy to install, as you simply have to plug them in and let them go.

Dehumidifiers are significantly more complicated than a fan. A dehumidifier functions by drawing air through an internal unit. There, it condenses are over cold coils to remove water from the air. Then, it pushes dry air back into the room. This doesn’t actually bring fresh air into the room, but it removes humidity from the air in the room.

Some quick differences to note These include:

  • A dehumidifier directly removes moisture from the air while a fan does not.
  • Even though both products have varying price points, a fan is usually less expensive than a dehumidifier.
  • A dehumidifier gives you direct control over the humidity level of a room while a fan does not.
  • Both products are relatively low-maintenance, but you do need to make sure they do not clog if you want them to work properly.

Looking at the Pros and Cons of a Fan

If you are considering placing a fan in your basement, it is important to understand the benefits and drawbacks. What do you need to know?

The Benefits of a Fan

A dog being cooled down by a fan
A dog being cooled down by a fan

A few of the top benefits of installing a fan include:

  • History: Fans have been used as a way to make sure homes are well-ventilated for decades. During this time, technology has improved significantly, making fans far more reliable. Furthermore, there are numerous options on the market, allow you to customize your individual fan to meet your specific needs.
  • Price: Fans are also incredibly inexpensive. Even though you can certainly spring for a more expensive fan if you would like, it is not difficult to find a good fan for a few dollars. If you are on a tight budget, then you may want to consider installing a fan.
  • Fresh Air: A fan will also provide you with fresh air in the room. By making sure the air circulates, you can prevent the air from going stale. Therefore, this is a great solution for people who suffer from chronic respiratory conditions including asthma, allergies, and chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD).
  • Easy To Install: Furthermore, fans are also very easy to install. For example, you may get a standing fan for the room which you simply have to plug in and turn on. Even if you are looking for a unit you can install in the wall or window, it is still relatively easy to use. You can fit them into your windows or events, bringing in air from the outside world.
  • Easy To Maintain: Fans are also very easy to maintain. You do not necessarily have to take it apart routinely just to clean it. You simply have to keep an eye on the filter, replacing this when it gets dirty. If you decided to go with a standing fan, you simply have to clean the exterior. That way, the air coming from the fan does not get blocked.

These are just a few of the top benefits of installing a fan in your basement. Of course, it is important to compare these benefits to the drawbacks as well. What should you know?

The Drawbacks of Installing a Fan

A few of the main drawbacks of installing a fan include:

  • Does Not Remove Humidity: If the big problem you are trying to tackle in your basement is dampness, then a fan is only going to help you so much. Even though you may be bringing in some dry or air from the outside, the fan is not going to do a good job of removing moisture that is actually in the room. If you are trying to reduce the humidity of the basement, then you should cover the dehumidifier instead.
  • A Fan Can Clog: In addition, it is relatively easy for a fan to get clogged. It is the job of the filter to remove dust and debris from the air. Because the fan is essentially one giant moving part, a single clog in the system can instantly bring the entire fan to a halt. Furthermore, if you try to ask the phantom power through this clog, you are going to burn the motor. As a result, the motor could end up dying, forcing you to replace the fan early.
  • A Fan Could Make Humidity Worse: There are also specific situations where having a fan might make your humidity problem worse. If you have a fan that is bringing in air from the outside, and you live in a warm environment, you might be bringing the air from the exterior. As a result, the moisture in the air could start to increase, making the problem in the basement worse.
  • A Fan Could Work Against the Air Conditioner: Furthermore, if you are bringing in air from the outside, your fan could start working against the air conditioner. Your air conditioner is working hard to keep the house cool, but if your fan is bringing in warm air from the outside, this could cause the basement to warm up. Furthermore, when the cold air and warm air collide, this could cause moisture to condense, worsening the moisture problem.

You need to compare these drawbacks to the benefits if you are trying to decide if a fan is right for you. Even though there are certain situations where a fan could be the right answer, there are other situations where you may want to go with something else.

Looking at the Pros and Cons of a Dehumidifier

A woman changing the water tank in a dehumidifier
A woman changing the water tank in a dehumidifier

Next, it is important to take a closer look at the benefits and drawbacks of a dehumidifier. Is this the right option for you?

The Benefits of a Dehumidifier

There are several benefits you will enjoy if you decide to go with a dehumidifier in your basement. A few of the top benefits include:

  • It Removes Water from the Air: First, a dehumidifier has been specifically designed to remove moisture from the air. If you have a significant moisture problem in the basement, a dehumidifier can tackle this. It will take air from the room, force it through the internal coils, dry out the air, and return the air to the room. You can actually see the dehumidifier go to work by taking a look at the moisture that gathers in the collection bucket.
  • Prevent Mold and Mildew: One of the beneficial side effects of using a dehumidifier in your basement is that you can prevent mold and mildew from growing. Mold and mildew require moisture in order to grow. If you remove moisture from the air, you can reduce the chances of having mold and mildew develop in your basement. This can be particularly beneficial for those with chronic respiratory conditions including allergies and asthma.
  • You Control the Humidity Level: There are also situations where you may want to prevent the air from getting too dry. Now, the vast majority of dehumidifiers allow you to control the humidity level. There is usually a preset limit you can use to make sure the air does not dry out too much. You can balance the moisture level in the air to make sure everyone is comfortable.
  • Low Maintenance: Even though you do have to do some work on the dehumidifier, it still does not take up much of your time. You need to make sure the dehumidifier is cleaned regularly so that it continues to work properly. You also need to empty the collection bucket from time to time and make sure it does not overflow.

You should keep these benefits in mind if you are trying to decide if a dehumidifier is right for you. Then, you should balance them with a few drawbacks.

The Drawbacks of a Dehumidifier

At the same time, there are a few drawbacks of having a dehumidifier that you should know. These include:

  • You Cannot Overlook the Collection Bucket: when your dehumidifier is running, you cannot forget about the collection bucket. Even though it does not take long to empty, this is a problem if you go out of town. You need to make sure the collection bucket is emptied regularly, or it could overflow when you are gone. Even though you can turn off the dehumidifier, this could lead to other problems in the basement.
  • The Pump System: if you do not want to empty the collection bucket regularly, then you may have to set up a drain pump system. You may need a professional to help you do this. Furthermore, you need to maintain your pump system, which will add to your to-do list. Even though this may be right for some people, this is not necessarily right for everyone.
  • Noise: furthermore, dehumidifiers can also be noisy. They come in all shapes and sizes, so you can customize your dehumidifier to meet your needs; however, the more powerful the dehumidifier is, the more noise that is going to make. This is something you need to keep in mind when you are deciding where you want to put your dehumidifier.
  • Size: in addition, dehumidifiers tend to take up more space than a fan. There are often situations where you can install your fan in the floor, window, or vent. This is not the case with the dehumidifier, which tends to stand on the floor. Therefore, this can make it difficult for you to find a spot to put your dehumidifier where it will be out of the way.

Even though a dehumidifier is also relatively easy to install, there are several drawbacks you need to think about. You need to compare these drawbacks to the benefits so you can figure out which one is right for you.

How To Decide Which Is Right for You: A Fan or a Dehumidifier

A basement with various exposed wires and pipes
A basement with various exposed wires and pipes

So, how can you decide which of these options is best for you? A few important points to remember include:

  • If you are on a tight budget, a fan is usually less expensive than a humidifier. Remember that both products have a variety of price points, so you should always take a look at multiple options.
  • If you need something that will actually remove moisture from the air, then you should go with a dehumidifier. A fan is not going to remove moisture for you.
  • If you have a relatively limited amount of space, a fan is usually smaller than a dehumidifier.
  • If you are sensitive to noise, you may want to go with a fan instead of a dehumidifier. A dehumidifier tends to be noisy.
  • Even though both options are relatively low maintenance, a dehumidifier does require slightly more maintenance work than a fan.

If you have questions or concerns about how a fan or dehumidifier might work for your individual situation, you may want to reach out to a professional who can help you. That way, you find the best possible option for your basement.

Frequently Asked Questions About Fans and Dehumidifiers

There are several common questions people ask about fans and dehumidifiers. These include:

How long do fans and dehumidifiers last?

It depends on how frequently you use them. The more you run them, the faster they are going to burn out. In general, you should expect to get between five and ten years of use out of your fans and dehumidifiers.

Are fans and dehumidifiers expensive to maintain?

No, they are not that expensive to maintain. On the other hand, they can be time-consuming. You do not necessarily have to purchase replacement parts, but you do have to clean them. In addition, you need to dump out the collection bucket of the dehumidifier regularly.

Why do I want dry air in my basement?

You do not want the air to be too dry, but removing moisture from the air can be helpful if you have mold or mildew growth in your basement. This is particularly important for people who suffer from respiratory conditions.

Charlie D Paige profile pic
About Charlie D Paige

Charlie is a massive DIY fan, with dozens of DIY projects under his belt - ranging from tiling to electrics, and concrete pads to walls. Charlie loves tinkering, seeing how things works, the outdoors and playing with power tools... so is it any wonder that he's completed so many DIY jobs over the years?

Charlie loves spreading his hard-won DIY experience with the world via this blog.